Gahanna Commission Approves Variances for Sort and Pack on Taylor Station Road
The Planning Commission backed an unpaved fire lane despite city staff objections and legal warnings over emergency vehicle damage.
The Gahanna Planning Commission met Sept. 9 to consider a variance application for Sort and Pack, Inc. at 650 Taylor Station Road, concluding the hearing with the item Approved. City planning staff recommended disapproval of the variance allowing asphalt millings, noting that the commission originally approved an asphalt fire lane and found no unique circumstances necessitating the change. Assistant City Attorney Matt Roth warned commissioners that Gahanna could potentially face liability, noting that the city adopted its code requirements for a reason. Roth added that while the city holds certain legal immunities, an outside party could still pursue a claim if an incident occurred, such as damage to a fire truck caused by an inadequate base.
The requests arose after an October 2024 inspection identified several inconsistencies between the site, the zoning code, and approved 2022 plans. In March 2022, the commission approved a 50,000-square-foot addition to the existing office and warehouse building. While 2022 plans approved asphalt, the applicant installed asphalt millings of approximately two to four inches of stone and concrete millings beneath five to six inches of asphalt millings.
Because the area served as a fire lane, staff consulted the Mifflin Township Division of Fire regarding the proposed surface. Mifflin Fire indicated it would accept asphalt millings if the applicant provided a uniform six-inch stone base topped with six inches of asphalt millings, for a total depth of 12 inches. John Ranft, a consultant for applicant Renee Claxton, explained that excavation showed the installed material fell a few inches short of the required specifications. Ranft reiterated that the applicant would reconstruct the fire lane under the fire department's supervision if the commission approved the use of asphalt millings.
The application also requested variances for several other site alterations. The first concerned an existing utility hot box, an accessory structure measuring approximately nine feet tall and 164 square feet located just under 75 feet from the right-of-way. Staff stated that the applicant installed the structure at the request of city utility staff but did not receive planning or zoning approval before construction. Staff explained that they supported the dumpster variance because the site provided no space for a dumpster behind the main building. The final variance concerned six parking lot trees, with the applicant proposing two-caliper-inch trees rather than the required minimum of three caliper inches planted around the perimeter. Ranft stated that a paving contractor paved over the triangular planting areas, and the property owner chose to plant the required number of trees around the perimeter rather than remove the asphalt. Ranft confirmed to Chair Sarah Pollyea that the applicant sought the variance because the work had already occurred.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
Planning Commission · 2026-09-09
Supporting evidence (20)
The Gahanna Planning Commission met Sept. 9 to consider a variance application for Sort and Pack, Inc. at 650 Taylor Station Road, concluding the hearing with the item Approved.
Read supporting passage
Gahanna Planning Commission met in regular session on September 9, 2026.
The Gahanna Planning Commission met Sept. 9 to consider a variance application for Sort and Pack, Inc. at 650 Taylor Station Road, concluding the hearing with the item Approved.
Read supporting passage
V-0017-2026 · To consider a Variance Application to vary Sections 1103.15(e) - Innovation and Manufacturing; 1109.01(f)(6) and 1109.01(h)(1) - Parking, Access, and Circulation; and 1109.02(e) - Setbacks and Structure Placement of the Codified Ordinances of the City of Gahanna; for property located at 650 Taylor Station Road; Parcel ID 025-013386; Current Zoning IM - Innovation & Manufacturing; Sort and Pack, Inc.; Renee Claxton, applicant.
The Gahanna Planning Commission met Sept. 9 to consider a variance application for Sort and Pack, Inc. at 650 Taylor Station Road, concluding the hearing with the item Approved.
Read supporting passage
Approved · · UNFINISHED BUSINESS - None
City planning staff recommended disapproval of the variance allowing asphalt millings, noting that the commission originally approved an asphalt fire lane and found no unique circumstances necessitating the change.
Read supporting passage
Staff recommended disapproval of the variance allowing asphalt millings in place of asphalt or concrete. Capka noted that the Commission originally approved an asphalt fire lane and found no unique circumstances that necessitated the variance.
Assistant City Attorney Matt Roth warned commissioners that Gahanna could potentially face liability, noting that the city adopted its code requirements for a reason.
Read supporting passage
Assistant City Attorney Roth stated that the city could potentially face liability and noted that the city adopted its code requirements for a reason.
Roth added that while the city holds certain legal immunities, an outside party could still pursue a claim if an incident occurred, such as damage to a fire truck caused by an inadequate base.
Read supporting passage
Assistant City Attorney Roth continued that the city had certain immunities but that a party could potentially pursue a claim if an incident occurred, such as damage to a fire truck caused by an inadequate base.
The requests arose after an October 2024 inspection identified several inconsistencies between the site, the zoning code, and approved 2022 plans.
Read supporting passage
During an October 2024 Planning Commission inspection, staff identified several inconsistencies between the site, the zoning code, and the approved 2022 plans. Staff subsequently required the applicant to submit new variance and development plan applications to address those inconsistencies.
In March 2022, the commission approved a 50,000-square-foot addition to the existing office and warehouse building.
Read supporting passage
In March 2022, the Planning Commission approved design review, final development plan, and variance applications for a 50,000-square-foot addition to the existing office and warehouse building.
While 2022 plans approved asphalt, the applicant installed asphalt millings of approximately two to four inches of stone and concrete millings beneath five to six inches of asphalt millings.
Read supporting passage
The Planning Commission approved asphalt for the fire lane as part of the 2022 applications, but the applicant installed asphalt millings instead. The existing fire lane consisted of approximately two to four inches of stone/concrete millings beneath approximately five to six inches of asphalt millings.
Because the area served as a fire lane, staff consulted the Mifflin Township Division of Fire regarding the proposed surface.
Read supporting passage
Because the area served as a fire lane, staff consulted Mifflin Township Division of Fire regarding the proposed surface.
Mifflin Fire indicated it would accept asphalt millings if the applicant provided a uniform six-inch stone base topped with six inches of asphalt millings, for a total depth of 12 inches.
Read supporting passage
Mifflin Fire indicated that it would accept asphalt millings if the applicant provided a uniform six-inch stone base topped with six inches of asphalt millings, for a total depth of 12 inches.
John Ranft, a consultant for applicant Renee Claxton, explained that excavation showed the installed material fell a few inches short of the required specifications.
Read supporting passage
John Ranft identified himself as the general contractor, a real estate broker, and a real estate consultant for the applicant, Renee Claxton.
John Ranft, a consultant for applicant Renee Claxton, explained that excavation showed the installed material fell a few inches short of the required specifications.
Read supporting passage
The excavation showed that the installed material fell a few inches short of the required specifications. Ranft stated that the fire chief wanted to ensure that the surface could safely support fire apparatus.
Ranft reiterated that the applicant would reconstruct the fire lane under the fire department's supervision if the commission approved the use of asphalt millings.
Read supporting passage
Ranft reiterated that the applicant would reconstruct the fire lane to the required specifications under the fire department's supervision if the Commission approved the use of asphalt millings.
The first concerned an existing utility hot box, an accessory structure measuring approximately nine feet tall and 164 square feet located just under 75 feet from the right-of-way.
Read supporting passage
Capka described the first variance request, which concerned a hot box, an accessory structure located in front of the primary structure. The structure measured approximately nine feet tall and 164 square feet and sat just under 75 feet from the right-of-way.
Staff stated that the applicant installed the structure at the request of city utility staff but did not receive planning or zoning approval before construction.
Read supporting passage
Staff stated that the applicant installed the structure at the request of City of Gahanna utility staff but did not receive Planning or Zoning approval before construction.
Staff explained that they supported the dumpster variance because the site provided no space for a dumpster behind the main building.
Read supporting passage
She explained that staff supported the dumpster variance because the site provided no space for a dumpster behind the main building.
The final variance concerned six parking lot trees, with the applicant proposing two-caliper-inch trees rather than the required minimum of three caliper inches planted around the perimeter.
Read supporting passage
The final variance concerned six parking lot trees. The applicant proposed trees measuring two caliper inches rather than the required minimum of three caliper inches and would plant all six around the perimeter of the parking area.
Ranft stated that a paving contractor paved over the triangular planting areas, and the property owner chose to plant the required number of trees around the perimeter rather than remove the asphalt.
Read supporting passage
Ranft stated that the paving contractor paved over the triangular planting areas. Afterward, the property owner chose to plant the required number of trees around the parking area's perimeter rather than remove the asphalt. He explained that this decision necessitated the variance.
Ranft confirmed to Chair Sarah Pollyea that the applicant sought the variance because the work had already occurred.
Read supporting passage
Chair Pollyea asked whether the applicant sought the variance for the owner's convenience because the work and tree planting had already occurred. Ranft confirmed that characterization.