Worthington Enacts Five-Year Curbside Food Waste Collection Contract
Worthington City Council approved a five-year contract with The Compost Exchange in a 4-3 vote despite administrative warnings over $1.035 million in unbudgeted costs.
Worthington City Council voted 4-3 on Oct. 19 to approve Ordinance No. 30-2026, authorizing a contract for residential food waste collection with lowest bidder TCE Columbus, LLC, doing business as The Compost Exchange. Under the approved legislation, the curbside food waste collection contract runs from Jan. 1, 2027, through Dec. 31, 2031.
In the 4-3 roll call vote, council members Pete Bucher, Rachael Dorothy, Amy Lloyd, and Glen Pratt voted in favor, while Joycelyn Dong, Rebecca Hermann, and Maria Ramirez voted against.
The City of Worthington Recycling Convenience Center features dedicated bays for food waste drop-off, electronics, motor oil, and styrofoam.
Credit: City of Worthington Image source
In an Oct. 14 staff memorandum regarding Ordinance No. 30-2026, Director of Service and Engineering John Moorehead and City Manager Robyn Stewart advised council to defeat the measure, stating that Worthington's proposed 2027 Operating Budget does not include funding for a curbside food waste collection program. Staff reported that the universal collection option adds $1,035,000 to city operating expenses over five years, equating to an annual budget expense of $207,000 at a monthly household rate of $3.28.
To assist with costs, SWACO is offering up to $100,000 in implementation assistance to help launch the service. Under Option #1, the $12,000 operating budget expense for the food waste drop-off service at the City's Recycling Convenience Center would be eliminated, as the drop-off service would be covered under the curbside collection contract.
Staff noted that adding the program without offsetting reductions draws on General Fund reserves, which is not sustainable for the longer term and creates pressure to reduce expenditures related to other services. To partially offset collection costs, staff noted the city could keep its social services coordinator part-time to save approximately $95,000 compared to a full-time position, or reallocate uncommitted housing funds from $500,000 in the 2026 Operating Budget. Staff also evaluated a suggestion from Pratt to delay Selby Shelter House renovations outside the five-year window by reducing transfers from the General Fund to the capital improvements program, cautioning that maintenance needs for the furnace and flooring cannot wait five years.
City Council directed staff on July 20 to advertise bids for curbside food waste collection, with bids solicited July 31 and opened on Aug. 21. Council introduced Ordinance No. 30-2026 on Sept. 8 for a public hearing on Sept. 21, when members voted unanimously to table the legislation until Oct. 19.
Pique’s reporting on the same events, newest first.
Worthington Latest
Worthington City Council Unanimously Adopts Comprehensive Master Plan
The Worthington Together blueprint updates land use and thoroughfare policies for the first time in nearly two decades, setting the stage for a 2027 zoning overhaul.
Worthington You are reading
Worthington Enacts Five-Year Curbside Food Waste Collection Contract
Worthington
Worthington Approves Fire Pact for Perry Township Project, Triggering Overhaul of 1999 Agreement
Council authorizes coverage for the Cottages at Brookside and sets a 180-day deadline to renegotiate township-wide emergency services.
Worthington
Worthington Seeks Federal Regional Grant to Replace Two Olentangy Trail Bridges
City Council approved Resolution No. 55-2026 to pursue MORPC grant funding for crossings near Tucker Drive and Whitney Avenue.
Worthington
Worthington Halts Flock License Plate Data Sharing With Outside Police Agencies
Worthington City Council suspended external data sharing from 14 Flock cameras pending regional guardrails, joining suburban pushback on surveillance.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
City Council Post-Meeting Reports · October 19, 2026 · other
Supporting evidence (3)
Worthington City Council voted 4-3 on Oct. 19 to approve Ordinance No. 30-2026, authorizing a contract for residential food waste collection with lowest bidder TCE Columbus, LLC, doing business as The Compost Exchange.
Read supporting passage
October 19, 2026 – City Council – Regular Meeting 1 | P a g e Members Present: President Rachael Dorothy, President Pro-tem Rebecca Hermann, Pete Bucher, Joycelyn Dong, Amy Lloyd, Glen Pratt and Maria Ramirez. Members Absent: None. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES Approval of Meeting Minutes Meeting minutes were presented from the June 8, June 15, and July 5, 2026 Regular Meetings, the July 3, 2026 Special Meeting and the July 6, 2026 Joint Meeting. COUNCIL ACTION: Councilmembers voted unanimously to approve the June 8, June 15, and July 5, 2026 Regular Meetings, the July 3, 2026 Special Meeting and the July 6, 2026 Joint Meeting. PUBLIC HEARINGS ON LEGISLATION Ordinance No. 30-2026 – Food Waste Collection and Disposal Contract This Ordinance authorizes the City Manager to enter into contract for the collection of food waste in the City of Worthington from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2031. COUNCIL ACTION: Council members voted to approve Ordinance No. 30-2026 by a vote of 4- 3.
Under the approved legislation, the curbside food waste collection contract runs from Jan. 1, 2027, through Dec. 31, 2031.
Read supporting passage
collection of food waste in the City of Worthington from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2031.
In the 4-3 roll call vote, council members Pete Bucher, Rachael Dorothy, Amy Lloyd, and Glen Pratt voted in favor, while Joycelyn Dong, Rebecca Hermann, and Maria Ramirez voted against.
Read supporting passage
Council members voted to approve Ordinance No. 30-2026 by a vote of 4- 3. Yeas: Bucher, Dorothy, Lloyd, Pratt Nays: Dong, Hermann, Ramirez
City Council Agendas · October 19, 2026 · agenda
Supporting evidence (10)
Worthington City Council voted 4-3 on Oct. 19 to approve Ordinance No. 30-2026, authorizing a contract for residential food waste collection with lowest bidder TCE Columbus, LLC, doing business as The Compost Exchange.
Read supporting passage
provide curbside food waste service to all residential households through a new city- funded program. Three bids were received for this option. TCE Columbus, LLC (The Compost Exchange) provided the lowest cost, responsive bid for Option #1 with a monthly per household rate of $3.28.
In an Oct. 14 staff memorandum regarding Ordinance No. 30-2026, Director of Service and Engineering John Moorehead and City Manager Robyn Stewart advised council to defeat the measure, stating that Worthington's proposed 2027 Operating Budget does not include funding for a curbside food waste collection program.
Read supporting passage
STAFF MEMORANDUM City Council Meeting – October 19, 2026 Date: October 14, 2026 To: City Council From: John Moorehead, Director of Service & Engineering Robyn Stewart, City Manager Subject: Ordinance No. 30-2026 Food Waste Collection and Disposal Contract EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Ordinance authorizes the City Manager to enter into contract for the collection of food waste in the City of Worthington from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2031. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends defeat of the Ordinance. As presented at the October 12 City Council meeting, Worthington’s proposed 2027 Operating Budget does not include funding for a curbside food waste collection program.
Staff reported that the universal collection option adds $1,035,000 to city operating expenses over five years, equating to an annual budget expense of $207,000 at a monthly household rate of $3.28.
Read supporting passage
TCE Columbus, LLC (The Compost Exchange) provided the lowest cost, responsive bid for Option #1 with a monthly per household rate of $3.28. Optional Bid #2 requested that haulers offer pricing to service only the interested households within Worthington. Under this option, residential households who elect to take part in curbside food waste collection would subscribe directly with the chosen hauler. Food waste collection fees would be paid by each individual subscriber. Three bids were also received for this option. The Compost Exchange and Local Waste Services both provided the lowest cost, responsive bid for Option #2 with a monthly per household rate of $15.00. In evaluating the results for both options, staff believes Option #2 offers limited benefits to the community. Curbside food waste collection is already available in Worthington through privately offered subscription plans. Some subscribers pay less than $15.00 per month for those services, making a city awarded option more expensive than what is already available. Therefore, staff does not recommend awarding Option #2. Bid results for Option #1 are competitive with pricing seen in other Central Ohio communities and would be supported by SWACO’s financial and technical assistance. Provision of curbside food waste collection would have the anticipated benefit of additional diversion of food waste from the landfill. SWACO’s grant support for this option is conditioned on the City’s implementation of curbside food waste collection for at least 5 years. The Compost Exchange’s bid price for Option #1 equates to an annual Operating Budget expense of $207,000. If offered over a 5-year period, this option adds a total of $1,035,000 to the City’s operating expenses.
To assist with costs, SWACO is offering up to $100,000 in implementation assistance to help launch the service.
Read supporting passage
SWACO is offering direct financial support in an amount not to exceed $100,000 to facilitate implementation of this service.
Under Option #1, the $12,000 operating budget expense for the food waste drop-off service at the City's Recycling Convenience Center would be eliminated, as the drop-off service would be covered under the curbside collection contract.
Read supporting passage
Worthington’s Operating Budget currently provides $12,000 towards the operation of a food waste drop-off service at the City’s Recycling Convenience Center. If Option #1 were authorized, that $12,000 expense would be eliminated, as the drop-off service would be covered under the curbside collection contract.
Staff noted that adding the program without offsetting reductions draws on General Fund reserves, which is not sustainable for the longer term and creates pressure to reduce expenditures related to other services.
Read supporting passage
The program can be added to the budget without offsetting reductions which will use the General Fund balance to support the program. This is not sustainable for the longer term without additional revenue and/or expenditure cuts elsewhere. It also reduces the ability to use fund balance to offset underperforming revenue or unexpected expenditures and creates pressure to reduce expenditures related to other services.
To partially offset collection costs, staff noted the city could keep its social services coordinator part-time to save approximately $95,000 compared to a full-time position, or reallocate uncommitted housing funds from $500,000 in the 2026 Operating Budget.
Read supporting passage
The Coordinator position could be kept part-time as a partial offset of the cost of food waste collection. The difference between the budget for full-time and the current level of part-time hours is approximately $95,000.
To partially offset collection costs, staff noted the city could keep its social services coordinator part-time to save approximately $95,000 compared to a full-time position, or reallocate uncommitted housing funds from $500,000 in the 2026 Operating Budget.
Read supporting passage
The 2026 Operating Budget includes $500,000 for housing initiatives that have not yet been identified. While this is one-time funding and not recurring, it could be used to offset the cost of food waste collection in the first few years.
Staff also evaluated a suggestion from Pratt to delay Selby Shelter House renovations outside the five-year window by reducing transfers from the General Fund to the capital improvements program, cautioning that maintenance needs for the furnace and flooring cannot wait five years.
Read supporting passage
Council Member Pratt suggested the Selby Shelter House renovations included in the Proposed 2027-2031 CIP could be delayed outside of the five-year window to cover the cost of the first five years of food waste collection. Normally savings in the CIP Fund do not result in more funding available in the General Fund, however the proposed Budget and CIP include a transfer of funds from the General Fund to the CIP. This provides the option of reducing the transfer to keep funding in the General Fund. If that happens, reductions need to be made in the CIP. The Shelter House has maintenance needs that can’t wait five years or more, so if this option is selected, some funding needs to remain in the CIP to address problems with the furnace, flooring and other items.
City Council directed staff on July 20 to advertise bids for curbside food waste collection, with bids solicited July 31 and opened on Aug. 21.
Read supporting passage
On July 20, 2026, City Council directed staff to advertise for bid the collection of curbside food waste as an optional service alongside the City’s current collection of solid waste, yard waste, and recycling. Two optional bid packages were advertised, each providing a different means of expanding Worthington’s waste management programs to include food waste collection. Bids were solicited July 31, 2026, and opened at noon on Friday August 21, 2026.
City Council Post-Meeting Reports · September 8, 2026 · other
Supporting evidence (1)
Council introduced Ordinance No. 30-2026 on Sept. 8 for a public hearing on Sept. 21, when members voted unanimously to table the legislation until Oct. 19.
Read supporting passage
Council members introduced Ordinance No. 30-2026 for a public hearing on September 21, 2026.
City Council Post-Meeting Reports · September 21, 2026 · other
Supporting evidence (1)
Council introduced Ordinance No. 30-2026 on Sept. 8 for a public hearing on Sept. 21, when members voted unanimously to table the legislation until Oct. 19.
Read supporting passage
Council members voted unanimously to approve a motion to table Ordinance No. 30-2026 until the October 19,2026 meeting.