Politics Development Courts & legal · Development & real estate

Federal Zoning Lawsuit Over 5550 Britton Parkway in Hilliard Remains Open After Settlement Deadline

Court records show no dismissal or status report filed following an October deadline, while city officials approved a separate sign variance for the property.

Hilliard

Watch the video

Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. brought a federal lawsuit against the City of Hilliard over the former BMW Financial Services office at 5550 Britton Parkway.

In a Sept. 4, 2026 notation order, Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall recorded that the parties reported the case settled and ordered a status update by Oct. 19, 2026, unless an entry of dismissal was filed in the interim.

As of Nov. 20, 2026, federal court records show that no status report or dismissal appeared after that order. CourtListener docket entries likewise showed no dismissal or status report after Sept. 4, 2026.

A crowded municipal council chamber filled with seated and standing attendees listening to a public hearing.

Community members pack Hilliard City Council chambers on Nov. 12, 2024, during a public hearing regarding the former BMW Financial Services property at 5550 Britton Parkway.

Credit: The Hilliard Beacon Image source

According to municipal planning records, the property spans 14.88 acres in Britton Central Subarea B4. The commercial building was previously occupied by BMW Financial Services as a corporate office. On Aug. 6, 2024, occupant Noor Islamic Cultural Center secured a zoning certificate for an office use at the location.

In federal filings, plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. stated that it is an affiliated entity created to serve the Muslim community in Central Ohio. The organization bought the building after a foreclosure auction and submitted an application to revise the development plan for a mixed-use neighborhood center, including space dedicated to worship.

On Nov. 12, 2024, Hilliard City Council considered the proposed text modification. Council members voted 3-4 to defeat an amendment that would have permitted a community center allowing religious activities in up to approximately 20,000 square feet. Council then voted 0-7 to defeat Resolution 24-R-88. According to council minutes, Law Director Boggs stated that a no vote would keep the current zoning text in place, meaning office is the only entitled use.

Britton Parkway Holding filed its initial federal complaint on April 14, 2025, against the City of Hilliard, Hilliard City Council, and City Manager Michelle Crandall. The complaint alleged violations of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, equal protection, and the free exercise of religion. The plaintiff filed a supplemental complaint in September 2025, and Chief District Judge Sarah D. Morrison reassigned magistrate supervision to Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall in March 2026.

The Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council recorded that ordinances were passed on June 22, 2026, including a $250,000 appropriation to provide funds for Law Department contracts. In a June 8, 2026, Law Department memo, the city stated that its litigation costs had increased and noted that a portion would be reimbursed by insurance related to the Britton Parkway Holdings lawsuits.

A contemporary office reception area with illuminated Regus signage against a slatted vertical wood wall and pendant lights over the counter.

Regus business center reception and lounge inside the commercial office building at 5550 Britton Parkway in Hilliard.

Credit: NearU / Regus · Supplied image Image source

Meanwhile, local administrative reviews on the site have proceeded under existing zoning rules. During its October 8, 2026 meeting, the Hilliard Planning and Zoning Commission considered an application for NOOROHIO at 5550 BRITTON PARKWAY. The commission voted 5-0 for approval of the request to permit a wall sign with internal illumination. Under the commission's approval, the variance included the condition requiring that a new sign permit is obtained prior to installation.

According to the city staff report, the applicant proposed an illuminated channel-letter sign measuring 206.2 square feet. The staff report noted that the Britton Central development text requires wall signage to be externally lit or backlit. The administrative sign approval addressed illumination standards and did not alter the property's underlying office zoning classification.

Where the case stands

Although the parties reported reaching a settlement in September, no settlement terms, agreement, or consent order have been entered into the public record. Under the Sept. 4 court order, the parties were instructed to file a joint status report detailing the status of the settlement by Oct. 19, 2026, if an entry of dismissal had not been filed.

As of Nov. 20, 2026, the public docket shows no status report, dismissal or other entry after the Sept. 4 order.

How we know this

Primary records documenting this dispute include:

Correction: This story was updated to cite the federal court docket directly and to correct the description of the case's status and of a June 8 Hilliard Law Department memo.

Video Watch video 0:40

How we know this

The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.

  1. RECAP complaint, Doc. 1, Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. v. Hilliard, filed April 14, 2025, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    storage.courtlistener.com

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (7)
    • Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. brought a federal lawsuit against the City of Hilliard over the former BMW Financial Services office at 5550 Britton Parkway.

      Read supporting passage
      Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc., 5550 Britton Parkway, Hilliard, Ohio 43026. Defendants: City of Hilliard, Ohio; Hilliard, Ohio City Council; and Michelle Crandall, City Manager, in her official capacity.
    • Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. brought a federal lawsuit against the City of Hilliard over the former BMW Financial Services office at 5550 Britton Parkway.

      Read supporting passage
      It alleges BPH bought the former BMW Financial Services office at 5550 Britton Parkway after a foreclosure auction and applied through Application No. PZ-24-47 to revise the PUD development plan for a mixed-use neighborhood center, including a portion of the building dedicated to worship.
    • In federal filings, plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. stated that it is an affiliated entity created to serve the Muslim community in Central Ohio.

      Read supporting passage
      is an affiliate of the Noor Islamic Cultural Center and was created to serve and promote the needs of a growing Muslim community in Central Ohio.
    • The organization bought the building after a foreclosure auction and submitted an application to revise the development plan for a mixed-use neighborhood center, including space dedicated to worship.

      Read supporting passage
      It alleges BPH bought the former BMW Financial Services office at 5550 Britton Parkway after a foreclosure auction and applied through Application No. PZ-24-47 to revise the PUD development plan for a mixed-use neighborhood center, including a portion of the building dedicated to worship.
    • Britton Parkway Holding filed its initial federal complaint on April 14, 2025, against the City of Hilliard, Hilliard City Council, and City Manager Michelle Crandall.

      Read supporting passage
      Case 2:25-cv-00392, Doc. 1, filed 04/14/25. Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc., 5550 Britton Parkway, Hilliard, Ohio 43026. Defendants: City of Hilliard, Ohio; Hilliard, Ohio City Council; and Michelle Crandall, City Manager, in her official capacity.
    • The complaint alleged violations of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, equal protection, and the free exercise of religion.

      Read supporting passage
      Counts as labeled in the complaint: I, violation of RLUIPA substantial-burden provisions; II, RLUIPA equal-terms, 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc(b)(1); III, RLUIPA nondiscrimination, 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc(b)(2); IV, regulatory taking under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and the Ohio Constitution; V, violation of due process — void for vagueness, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and the Ohio Constitution; VI, equal protection; VII, substantive due process; VIII, free exercise of religion; IX, freedom of assembly; X, First Amendment retaliation; XI, declaratory judgment.
    • Federal complaint, filed April 14, 2025

      Read supporting passage
      Case 2:25-cv-00392, Doc. 1, filed 04/14/25. Plaintiff Britton Parkway Holding, Inc., 5550 Britton Parkway, Hilliard, Ohio 43026. Defendants: City of Hilliard, Ohio; Hilliard, Ohio City Council; and Michelle Crandall, City Manager, in her official capacity.
  2. PACER Monitor public docket for 2:25-cv-00392, observed Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    www.pacermonitor.com

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (3)
    • In a Sept. 4, 2026 notation order, Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall recorded that the parties reported the case settled and ordered a status update by Oct. 19, 2026, unless an entry of dismissal was filed in the interim.

      Read supporting passage
      The parties have reported this case as settled. The parties are directed to file a joint status report outlining the status, but not the substance, of the settlement by October 19, 2026, unless an appropriate entry of dismissal is filed in the interim. Signed by Magistrate Judge S. Courter M. Shimeall on 09/04/2026. (mrt)
    • As of Nov. 20, 2026, federal court records show that no status report or dismissal appeared after that order.

      Read supporting passage
      Observed Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET. Public PACER Monitor docket for Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. v. Hilliard et al., Ohio Southern District Court, Case #: 2:25-cv-00392.
    • As of Nov. 20, 2026, federal court records show that no status report or dismissal appeared after that order.

      Read supporting passage
      No joint status report and no dismissal appeared after Doc. 31 on this page.
  3. CourtListener docket, Britton Parkway Holding, Inc. v. Hilliard, 2:25-cv-00392, observed Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    www.courtlistener.com

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (3)
    • CourtListener docket entries likewise showed no dismissal or status report after Sept. 4, 2026.

      Read supporting passage
      No joint status report and no dismissal appeared on this CourtListener docket after Sept. 4, 2026.
    • The plaintiff filed a supplemental complaint in September 2025, and Chief District Judge Sarah D. Morrison reassigned magistrate supervision to Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall in March 2026.

      Read supporting passage
      Sept. 12, 2025, Doc. 22: COMPLAINT with JURY DEMAND (SUPPLEMENTAL) against All Defendants, filed by Britton Parkway Holding, Inc.
    • The plaintiff filed a supplemental complaint in September 2025, and Chief District Judge Sarah D. Morrison reassigned magistrate supervision to Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall in March 2026.

      Read supporting passage
      March 17, 2026, Doc. 26: ORDER REASSIGNING CASE to Magistrate Judge S. Courter Shimeall; Magistrate Judge Kimberly A. Jolson no longer assigned. Signed by Chief District Judge Sarah D. Morrison on 3/16/26.
  4. Hilliard PZ-26-57 staff report, NoorOhio sign variance at 5550 Britton Parkway, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (4)
    • According to municipal planning records, the property spans 14.88 acres in Britton Central Subarea B4.

      Read supporting passage
      The site is 14.88 acres located on the east side of Britton Parkway, the west side of I-270, and the north side of the eastern terminus of Riggins Court. It consists of Britton Central PUD Subarea B4.
    • On Aug. 6, 2024, occupant Noor Islamic Cultural Center secured a zoning certificate for an office use at the location.

      Read supporting passage
      The current occupant, Noor Islamic Cultural Center, obtained a Zoning Certificate for an office use on August 6, 2024.
    • According to the city staff report, the applicant proposed an illuminated channel-letter sign measuring 206.2 square feet.

      Read supporting passage
      The applicant is proposing to install a 206.2 square foot internally illuminated wall sign composed of channel letters.
    • The staff report noted that the Britton Central development text requires wall signage to be externally lit or backlit.

      Read supporting passage
      All wall-mounted signage shall be backlit or externally lighted.
  5. Hilliard PZ-24-47 staff report, 5550 Britton Parkway PUD text modification, Sept. 12, 2024, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (1)
    • The commercial building was previously occupied by BMW Financial Services as a corporate office.

      Read supporting passage
      Background states the building was previously occupied by BMW Financial Services as a corporate office
  6. Nov. 12, 2024 Hilliard City Council minutes (in Nov. 25, 2024 packet), captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (5)
    • Council members voted 3-4 to defeat an amendment that would have permitted a community center allowing religious activities in up to approximately 20,000 square feet.

      Read supporting passage
      Ms. Vermillion, seconded by Mr. Betts, moved to amend Resolution 24-R-88, including that a community center allowing various religious activities be treated as a permitted use, with the gross floor area of the community center not to exceed 10% of the building's square footage, approximately 20,000 square feet, plus other use and parking changes. STATUS: DEFEATED. 3-4.
    • Council then voted 0-7 to defeat Resolution 24-R-88.

      Read supporting passage
      Motion to adopt Resolution 24-R-88: MOVER: Ms. Vermillion. SECONDER: Ms. Hale. STATUS: Failed 0-7. AYES: (none listed). NAYS: Cottone, Teater, Betts, Carrier, Cole, Hale, and Vermillion.
    • According to council minutes, Law Director Boggs stated that a no vote would keep the current zoning text in place, meaning office is the only entitled use.

      Read supporting passage
      Law Director Boggs, as recorded in the minutes, said a no vote on the original resolution
    • According to council minutes, Law Director Boggs stated that a no vote would keep the current zoning text in place, meaning office is the only entitled use.

      Read supporting passage
      would mean that the current zoning text would remain in place, so the only use entitled to in the current zoning text is office.
    • Hilliard City Council regular minutes, Nov. 12, 2024

      Read supporting passage
      contains the official Regular Council Minutes for November 12, 2024, including Resolution 24-R-88
  7. Hilliard Legislative Bulletin, June 22, 2026 meeting, published June 23, 2026, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (4)
    • The Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council recorded that ordinances were passed on June 22, 2026, including a $250,000 appropriation to provide funds for Law Department contracts.

      Read supporting passage
      Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council.
    • The Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council recorded that ordinances were passed on June 22, 2026, including a $250,000 appropriation to provide funds for Law Department contracts.

      Read supporting passage
      The following Ordinances were passed on June 22, 2026.
    • The Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council recorded that ordinances were passed on June 22, 2026, including a $250,000 appropriation to provide funds for Law Department contracts.

      Read supporting passage
      which appropriates $250,000 from the General Fund, Fund 101, Object 53, to provide funds for Law Department Contracts.
    • Hilliard City Council Legislative Bulletin, June 22, 2026

      Read supporting passage
      Official Legislative Bulletin of Hilliard City Council. Meeting Date: June 22, 2026. Publication Date: June 23, 2026.
  8. Hilliard Law Department Contract Appropriation memo, June 8, 2026, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (1)
    • In a June 8, 2026, Law Department memo, the city stated that its litigation costs had increased and noted that a portion would be reimbursed by insurance related to the Britton Parkway Holdings lawsuits.

      Read supporting passage
      The City's litigation costs as it relates to disputes have increased over what was projected. A portion of the amount that is being requested will be reimbursed from the City's insurance company as it relates to the current suits involving Britton Parkway Holdings.
  9. Hilliard Planning & Zoning Commission minutes, Oct. 8, 2026, captured Nov. 20, 2026, 8:03 a.m. ET

    hilliardohio.civicweb.net

    Accessed

    Supporting evidence (6)
    • During its October 8, 2026 meeting, the Hilliard Planning and Zoning Commission considered an application for NOOROHIO at 5550 BRITTON PARKWAY.

      Read supporting passage
      Official meeting minutes, Planning & Zoning Commission, Thursday, October 8, 2026
    • During its October 8, 2026 meeting, the Hilliard Planning and Zoning Commission considered an application for NOOROHIO at 5550 BRITTON PARKWAY.

      Read supporting passage
      Consent Agenda item 1: PZ-26-57 - NOOROHIO - 5550 BRITTON PARKWAY.
    • The commission voted 5-0 for approval of the request to permit a wall sign with internal illumination.

      Read supporting passage
      Status: Approved (5-0).
    • The commission voted 5-0 for approval of the request to permit a wall sign with internal illumination.

      Read supporting passage
      to approve a sign variance under the provisions of Hilliard Code Section 1129.08 to permit a wall sign with internal illumination
    • Under the commission's approval, the variance included the condition requiring that a new sign permit is obtained prior to installation.

      Read supporting passage
      That a new sign permit is applied for and obtained prior to installation.
    • Planning and Zoning Commission minutes, Oct. 8, 2026

      Read supporting passage
      Official meeting minutes, Planning & Zoning Commission, Thursday, October 8, 2026

Take Pique with you

Your city. In your pocket.

Read local stories, watch the videos and explore the details in Pique.

QR code for Pique Media on the App Store

Get Pique for iPhone and iPad

Scan the code with your phone’s camera.

View on the App Store

Share this story