Judge Rules Mother Competent to Stand Trial in Hamden Case, Orders Inpatient Care for Grandmother
Vinton County Common Pleas Court rulings set divergent paths for family members as Elizabeth Siders pursues an insanity defense and Christina Siders enters competency restoration.
A judge found Elizabeth Siders competent to stand trial on Nov. 9, while grandmother Christina Siders was deemed incompetent and will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment. Both women appeared in Vinton County Court of Common Pleas on Monday for competency hearings following their arrests in June after children were found inside a room in a rental home in Hamden. The defendants all had psychiatric evaluations to determine whether they were competent to stand trial.
Elizabeth Siders appears in Vinton County Common Pleas Court wearing an orange jail jumpsuit, with her hand resting on her stomach as law enforcement stands nearby.
Credit: Doral Chenoweth / The Columbus Dispatch via Yahoo News Image source
While the court found Elizabeth Siders competent to face trial, defense attorney Tommy Stolly did not object to that finding but announced he will pursue an insanity defense. Under Ohio law, competency is based on a defendant’s current mental state, while an insanity defense is based on their mental state at the time of the alleged crimes. Stolly told reporters after the hearing that the initial joint evaluation conducted over Zoom in approximately 90 minutes was simply not enough to assess her mental condition. Noting that Elizabeth Siders has a right under law to seek a second evaluation, Stolly said he has been interviewing experts to conduct hours of interviews into how she grew up and the living conditions within the Siders household. Stolly also confirmed to reporters following the hearing that Elizabeth Siders is pregnant, though he did not provide a due date or additional details.
In contrast, psychological testing determined 67-year-old Christina Siders is incompetent to stand trial, though evaluators concluded she could potentially be restored to competency. Christina Siders will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment, and if she can be restored to competency, she would then stand trial. After testing noted signs of dementia, her defense counsel asked the court to fund an additional evaluation by a specialist.
The proceedings highlight contrasting outcomes across the four family members. Previously, Pique Media reported that Vinton County dismissed child endangerment charges against Gary Siders Sr. A judge dismissed his case after he was found incompetent, though he could still be committed to a facility. Meanwhile, father Gary Siders Jr., Elizabeth's husband, is also undergoing a competency evaluation, but the court has yet to schedule a hearing regarding his results.
Video Watch video 0:44
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/vinton-county-mother-found-competent-223754287.html
Supporting evidence (2)
A judge found Elizabeth Siders competent to stand trial on Nov. 9, while grandmother Christina Siders was deemed incompetent and will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment.
Read supporting passage
A judge found Elizabeth Siders, 34, the mother of 16 children discovered living in deplorable conditions in a home in the village of Hamden, about 80 miles south of Columbus in Vinton County, competent to stand trial on Nov. 9, according to Dispatch news partner NBC4 (WCMH-TV).
In contrast, psychological testing determined 67-year-old Christina Siders is incompetent to stand trial, though evaluators concluded she could potentially be restored to competency.
Read supporting passage
But Christina Siders, the 67-year-old grandmother of the children, was found not competent to stand trial, according to NBC4.
Supporting evidence (15)
A judge found Elizabeth Siders competent to stand trial on Nov. 9, while grandmother Christina Siders was deemed incompetent and will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment.
Read supporting passage
While Christina, the grandmother, was deemed incompetent to stand trial, the results from her psychological evaluation showed she could potentially be restored. She will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment. If she can be restored to competency, she would then stand trial.
Both women appeared in Vinton County Court of Common Pleas on Monday for competency hearings following their arrests in June after children were found inside a room in a rental home in Hamden.
Read supporting passage
Both women appeared in the Vinton County Court of Common Pleas on Monday for their competency hearings.
Both women appeared in Vinton County Court of Common Pleas on Monday for competency hearings following their arrests in June after children were found inside a room in a rental home in Hamden.
Read supporting passage
Mother Elizabeth Siders and grandmother Christina Siders were arrested in June along with two other family members after the children were found inside a room in a rental home in Hamden. All four were indicted on multiple felony counts of child endangerment.
The defendants all had psychiatric evaluations to determine whether they were competent to stand trial.
While the court found Elizabeth Siders competent to face trial, defense attorney Tommy Stolly did not object to that finding but announced he will pursue an insanity defense.
Read supporting passage
Elizabeth’s attorney, Tommy Stolly, did not object to the competency finding. However, he said he will request a second evaluation on the issue of insanity.
Under Ohio law, competency is based on a defendant’s current mental state, while an insanity defense is based on their mental state at the time of the alleged crimes.
Read supporting passage
The difference is that competency is based on a defendant’s current mental state. Insanity is based on the mental state at the time of the alleged crimes.
Stolly told reporters after the hearing that the initial joint evaluation conducted over Zoom in approximately 90 minutes was simply not enough to assess her mental condition.
Read supporting passage
“The fact that this evaluator conducted both of these evaluations at the same time via Zoom, and essentially spent approximately an hour and a half with my client — that is simply not enough to understand her mental condition,” Stolly told reporters after the hearing.
Noting that Elizabeth Siders has a right under law to seek a second evaluation, Stolly said he has been interviewing experts to conduct hours of interviews into how she grew up and the living conditions within the Siders household.
Read supporting passage
Elizabeth has a right under law to seek a second evaluation.
Noting that Elizabeth Siders has a right under law to seek a second evaluation, Stolly said he has been interviewing experts to conduct hours of interviews into how she grew up and the living conditions within the Siders household.
Read supporting passage
Stolly said he’s been interviewing experts, looking for someone to conduct the second evaluation. “And they tell me that it’s going to take hours and hours of time to interview not only Elizabeth but her family to get a complete understanding of how she grew up, what the conditions were like in the home when she was growing up, and potentially what these conditions were like when she was in the family with the rest of the Siders,” Stolly said.
Stolly also confirmed to reporters following the hearing that Elizabeth Siders is pregnant, though he did not provide a due date or additional details.
Read supporting passage
Stolly also confirmed to reporters after the hearing that Elizabeth is again pregnant, but did not provide a due date or any other details about the pregnancy.
In contrast, psychological testing determined 67-year-old Christina Siders is incompetent to stand trial, though evaluators concluded she could potentially be restored to competency.
Read supporting passage
While Christina, the grandmother, was deemed incompetent to stand trial, the results from her psychological evaluation showed she could potentially be restored.
Christina Siders will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment, and if she can be restored to competency, she would then stand trial.
Read supporting passage
While Christina, the grandmother, was deemed incompetent to stand trial, the results from her psychological evaluation showed she could potentially be restored. She will be sent to an inpatient facility for treatment. If she can be restored to competency, she would then stand trial.
After testing noted signs of dementia, her defense counsel asked the court to fund an additional evaluation by a specialist.
Read supporting passage
The evaluation also noted that Christina has signs of dementia. Her attorney is asking the court to pay for further evaluation by a specialist.
A judge dismissed his case after he was found incompetent, though he could still be committed to a facility.
Read supporting passage
Christina’s husband, Gary Siders Sr., has already been found incompetent and the judge dismissed his case last month. Gary Sr. could still be committed to a facility, however, and if so could end up spending as much time there as he might have spent in prison had he been tried and convicted.
Meanwhile, father Gary Siders Jr., Elizabeth's husband, is also undergoing a competency evaluation, but the court has yet to schedule a hearing regarding his results.
Read supporting passage
Gary Siders Jr., Elizabeth’s husband, is also undergoing a competency evaluation, but a hearing has yet to be scheduled regarding the results.
Vinton County Dismisses Child Endangerment Charges Against Gary Siders Sr.
Supporting evidence (1)
Previously, Pique Media reported that Vinton County dismissed child endangerment charges against Gary Siders Sr.
Read supporting passage
Vinton County Dismisses Child Endangerment Charges Against Gary Siders Sr.