Columbus City Council advances $172,000 sole-source water fire-safety contract
The proposed Water Operating Fund modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP would raise total contract authorization to $668,977.36 through Aug. 16, 2027, while legislative records show $0.00 spent in 2025 and a pending vendor listing.
Columbus City Council on Nov. 16 advanced a $172,000 sole-source contract modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life-safety system maintenance across Division of Water facilities.
Columbus City Council members meet inside City Council Chambers at Columbus City Hall on July 21, 2025. Council advanced a proposed $172,000 Division of Water life-safety contract modification to second reading on Nov. 16. (Photo by WOSU Public Media)
Credit: WOSU Public Media Image source
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading. Residents can use Ordinance 2976-2026 to locate the pending legislation on the city's docket ahead of final council action. Council is next scheduled to meet at 5 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, in City Council Chambers, though the agenda for that session is not yet available.
Under the proposed modification, Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, would provide inspections, diagnostic tests and repairs for fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components across Division of Water facilities. The agreement covers 24-hour emergency fire alarm service, detector cleaning, component logging, panel and peripheral replacement, and functional testing under National Fire Protection Association 72 standards.
Multi-year contract history
City legislative records show the agreement began with an initial one-year sole-source contract authorized in 2023 under Chapter 329 of the Columbus City Code, running through June 28, 2024, with options for four annual renewals.
Council subsequently approved three renewals before the pending proposal:
- A first renewal added $90,000 and extended the contract through Aug. 16, 2025.
- A second renewal option added $174,750 and extended coverage through July 28, 2026.
- A third renewal option added $143,108.03 through Aug. 16, 2027, specifically for the Division of Water Reclamation.
The pending $172,000 modification for the Division of Water would fund services through Aug. 16, 2027, bringing the total contract authorization to $668,977.36.
An elevated view of treatment basins and facility structures at the City of Columbus's Hap Cremean Water Plant. (Photo via Burgess & Niple)
Credit: Burgess & Niple Image source
Unanswered oversight questions
The public legislative text leaves four oversight questions for Columbus utility ratepayers:
Recorded spending
The ordinance's fiscal impact section states that $0.00 was spent in 2025 and $52,498.53 has been spent in 2026, even though earlier renewals added $90,000 through Aug. 16, 2025, and $174,750 through July 28, 2026. The legislative text does not explain why no spending was recorded during 2025.
Interim Division of Water coverage
The second renewal extended the contract through July 28, 2026, and the third renewal extended coverage through Aug. 16, 2027, for the Division of Water Reclamation, while the proposed ordinance modifies the agreement "to include the Division of Water" through Aug. 16, 2027. The ordinance does not state how Division of Water fire-safety systems were covered after July 28, 2026.
Sole-source rationale and attachments
The ordinance states it is submitted under Chapter 329 of City Code because the vendor "is the sole provider of this service," while listing five supporting PDF attachments, including a sole-source letter and sole-source form. The ordinance text does not detail whether proprietary fire-alarm panels or equipment preclude competitive bidding, and the contents of those five PDF files are not summarized in the legislation.
Pending vendor status
The ordinance lists Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP as "CC: PENDING" while the legislation stands at second reading. The legislative text does not state when the vendor's contract compliance status will be finalized.
If approved, the ordinance would take effect at the earliest period allowed by law.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
Supporting evidence (33)
Columbus City Council on Nov. 16 advanced a $172,000 sole-source contract modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life-safety system maintenance across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
11/16/20261 Columbus City Council
Columbus City Council on Nov. 16 advanced a $172,000 sole-source contract modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life-safety system maintenance across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
Second Reading
Columbus City Council on Nov. 16 advanced a $172,000 sole-source contract modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life-safety system maintenance across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
To authorize the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing sole source agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life safety system maintenance services; and to authorize the expenditure of $172,000.00 from within the Water Operating Fund. ($172,000.00)
Columbus City Council on Nov. 16 advanced a $172,000 sole-source contract modification with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life-safety system maintenance across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
This ordinance authorizes the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, for life safety system maintenance services. The contract amount being authorized by this ordinance is $172,000.00 for the Division of Water.
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
To authorize the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing sole source agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP for life safety system maintenance services; and to authorize the expenditure of $172,000.00 from within the Water Operating Fund. ($172,000.00)
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
This ordinance authorizes the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, for life safety system maintenance services. The contract amount being authorized by this ordinance is $172,000.00 for the Division of Water.
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
File created: 10/19/2026
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
2976-2026
The Water Operating Fund measure, an ordinance under the Public Utilities & Sustainability Committee whose file was created Oct. 19 as 2976-2026, stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
Second Reading
Under the proposed modification, Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, would provide inspections, diagnostic tests and repairs for fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
This contract, also known as FEM 1390.3, will provide for inspections, diagnostic tests and repairs for all accessible peripheral devices currently connected to the life safety systems.
Under the proposed modification, Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, would provide inspections, diagnostic tests and repairs for fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
These systems include the fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components that protect the assets contained in the various facilities. The contract will provide for repair and necessary documentation to log all accessible components and devices, detector cleaning for fire alarm and detection systems, emergency service call and labor for the fire alarm 24 hours, 7 days a week, and panel and peripheral component replacement for the various electronic systems. Under the contract, the accessible peripheral devices will be functionally tested in accordance with the National Fire Protection Association’s 72 (NFPA) and manufacturer’s recommended procedures.
Under the proposed modification, Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, would provide inspections, diagnostic tests and repairs for fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components across Division of Water facilities.
Read supporting passage
This ordinance authorizes the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, for life safety system maintenance services. The contract amount being authorized by this ordinance is $172,000.00 for the Division of Water.
The agreement covers 24-hour emergency fire alarm service, detector cleaning, component logging, panel and peripheral replacement, and functional testing under National Fire Protection Association 72 standards.
Read supporting passage
These systems include the fire alarm detection and fire sprinkler components that protect the assets contained in the various facilities. The contract will provide for repair and necessary documentation to log all accessible components and devices, detector cleaning for fire alarm and detection systems, emergency service call and labor for the fire alarm 24 hours, 7 days a week, and panel and peripheral component replacement for the various electronic systems. Under the contract, the accessible peripheral devices will be functionally tested in accordance with the National Fire Protection Association’s 72 (NFPA) and manufacturer’s recommended procedures.
City legislative records show the agreement began with an initial one-year sole-source contract authorized in 2023 under Chapter 329 of the Columbus City Code, running through June 28, 2024, with options for four annual renewals.
Read supporting passage
The original contract was established in accordance with the pertinent provisions for Sole Source Procurement of Chapter 329 of the Columbus City Code and authorized under Ordinance No. 1342-2023. Services under the original contract cover a one (1) year period, from date of execution up to and including June 28th, 2024, with the option to renew for four additional years, for a max contract length of five years, based upon mutual agreement, availability of budgeted funds and approval of Columbus City Council.
A first renewal added $90,000 and extended the contract through Aug. 16, 2025.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 0670-2024 authorized the first renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $90,000.00 and extending the contract through August 16th, 2025.
A second renewal option added $174,750 and extended coverage through July 28, 2026.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 1432-2025 authorized the second renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $174,750.00 and extending the contract through July 28th, 2026.
A third renewal option added $143,108.03 through Aug. 16, 2027, specifically for the Division of Water Reclamation.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 1540-2026 authorized the third renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $143,108.03 and extending the contract through August 16th, 2027 for the Division of Water Reclamation.
The pending $172,000 modification for the Division of Water would fund services through Aug. 16, 2027, bringing the total contract authorization to $668,977.36.
Read supporting passage
This ordinance authorizes the Director of Columbus Water and Power to modify an existing agreement with Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, formerly SimplexGrinnell LP, for life safety system maintenance services. The contract amount being authorized by this ordinance is $172,000.00 for the Division of Water.
The pending $172,000 modification for the Division of Water would fund services through Aug. 16, 2027, bringing the total contract authorization to $668,977.36.
Read supporting passage
1. Amount of additional funds: Total amount of additional funds needed for this contract modification is to add $172,000.00. Total contract amount including this modification is $668,977.36. 2. Reason additional funds were not foreseen: The need for additional funds was known at the time of the initial contract. This modification is to provide the additional funding necessary for the payment of services provided through August 16th, 2027.
The ordinance's fiscal impact section states that $0.00 was spent in 2025 and $52,498.53 has been spent in 2026, even though earlier renewals added $90,000 through Aug. 16, 2025, and $174,750 through July 28, 2026.
Read supporting passage
$52,498.53 has been spent so far in 2026 $0.00 was spent in 2025
The ordinance's fiscal impact section states that $0.00 was spent in 2025 and $52,498.53 has been spent in 2026, even though earlier renewals added $90,000 through Aug. 16, 2025, and $174,750 through July 28, 2026.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 0670-2024 authorized the first renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $90,000.00 and extending the contract through August 16th, 2025.
The ordinance's fiscal impact section states that $0.00 was spent in 2025 and $52,498.53 has been spent in 2026, even though earlier renewals added $90,000 through Aug. 16, 2025, and $174,750 through July 28, 2026.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 1432-2025 authorized the second renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $174,750.00 and extending the contract through July 28th, 2026.
The second renewal extended the contract through July 28, 2026, and the third renewal extended coverage through Aug. 16, 2027, for the Division of Water Reclamation, while the proposed ordinance modifies the agreement "to include the Division of Water" through Aug. 16, 2027.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 1432-2025 authorized the second renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $174,750.00 and extending the contract through July 28th, 2026.
The second renewal extended the contract through July 28, 2026, and the third renewal extended coverage through Aug. 16, 2027, for the Division of Water Reclamation, while the proposed ordinance modifies the agreement "to include the Division of Water" through Aug. 16, 2027.
Read supporting passage
Ordinance 1540-2026 authorized the third renewal option, increasing funding allocations by $143,108.03 and extending the contract through August 16th, 2027 for the Division of Water Reclamation.
The second renewal extended the contract through July 28, 2026, and the third renewal extended coverage through Aug. 16, 2027, for the Division of Water Reclamation, while the proposed ordinance modifies the agreement "to include the Division of Water" through Aug. 16, 2027.
Read supporting passage
WHEREAS, The Department of Public Utilities wishes to modify the sole source contract and provide additional funding for the same services as under the original agreement to include the Division of Water; and
The second renewal extended the contract through July 28, 2026, and the third renewal extended coverage through Aug. 16, 2027, for the Division of Water Reclamation, while the proposed ordinance modifies the agreement "to include the Division of Water" through Aug. 16, 2027.
Read supporting passage
1. Amount of additional funds: Total amount of additional funds needed for this contract modification is to add $172,000.00. Total contract amount including this modification is $668,977.36. 2. Reason additional funds were not foreseen: The need for additional funds was known at the time of the initial contract. This modification is to provide the additional funding necessary for the payment of services provided through August 16th, 2027.
The ordinance states it is submitted under Chapter 329 of City Code because the vendor "is the sole provider of this service," while listing five supporting PDF attachments, including a sole-source letter and sole-source form.
Read supporting passage
This ordinance authorizes the first modification option of the contract, and is being submitted in accordance with the relevant provisions of Chapter 329 of City Code.
The ordinance states it is submitted under Chapter 329 of City Code because the vendor "is the sole provider of this service," while listing five supporting PDF attachments, including a sole-source letter and sole-source form.
Read supporting passage
3. Reason other procurement processes were not used: The vendor is the sole provider of this service.
The ordinance states it is submitted under Chapter 329 of City Code because the vendor "is the sole provider of this service," while listing five supporting PDF attachments, including a sole-source letter and sole-source form.
Read supporting passage
1. ORD 2976-2026 - Additional Information.pdf, 2. ORD 2976-2026 Financials.pdf, 3. ORD 2976-2026 Johnson Controls Sole Source Letter.pdf, 4. ORD 2976-2026 Sole Source Form - Johnson Controls.pdf, 5. ORD 2976-2026 Johnson Controls SOS.pdf
The ordinance lists Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP as "CC: PENDING" while the legislation stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
VENDOR: Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP; Vendor# 009524; CC: PENDING
The ordinance lists Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP as "CC: PENDING" while the legislation stands at second reading.
Read supporting passage
Second Reading
If approved, the ordinance would take effect at the earliest period allowed by law.
Read supporting passage
SECTION 6. That this ordinance shall take effect and be in force from and after the earliest period allowed by law.
https://columbus.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx?Mode=ThisMonth
Supporting evidence (1)
Council is next scheduled to meet at 5 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, in City Council Chambers, though the agenda for that session is not yet available.
Read supporting passage
Columbus City Council 11/23/2026 5:00 PM City Council Chambers, Rm 231 Meeting details Not available