Ohio State Ranks Ninth in Conservative Think Tank's College Rankings
City Journal, published by the conservative Manhattan Institute, ranked Ohio State high for governance and civics despite bottom-tier career earnings and payback.
In college rankings published by City Journal, Ohio State University placed ninth overall with an overall weighted score of 67.38 out of 100. City Journal is published by the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank.
Smith Laboratory on the Columbus campus of The Ohio State University.
Credit: Blervis / Wikimedia Commons Image source
Ohio State's top-10 placement was marked by stark internal contrasts: while the university scored near the top in governance and civics metrics, it ranked 101st in Value Added to Career with a score of 4.60 out of 16, and 83rd for payback on education investment with 7.30 out of 13.
According to the index's methodology, the evaluation scored 115 colleges on 95 variables across campus governance, educational experience, student life, and career outcomes, leaving out measures of past prestige, admissions selectivity, or incoming test scores. Instead, the think tank's model assigned heavy weight to ideological and governance priorities, including viewpoint diversity through "Heterodox Infrastructure" and "Commitment to Meritocracy". Across all 115 colleges evaluated, no institution scored above 80, with the publisher reporting an average nationwide score of 50.
Strong Marks for Governance and Civics
On its institutional profile page, Ohio State earned a score of 20.20 out of 30 for educational quality, ranking fifth in that category. In the category's underlying breakdown, Ohio State ranked second nationwide for heterodox infrastructure. In its summary of that infrastructure, the profile notes that the Salmon P. Chase Center for Civics, Culture, and Society, established by the Ohio General Assembly in 2023, exposes students to foundational debates on constitutional order, free societies, and responsible citizenship.
The Manhattan Institute also ranked Ohio State fourth nationally for commitment to meritocracy. The profile states that the university reaffirmed that commitment as faculty job postings no longer require diversity statements or express preferences for minority candidates, and protected-class criteria have been eliminated from scholarship awards.
Career Earnings and Payback Lag
In sharp contrast to its governance standing, Ohio State struggled in career metrics, placing 101st in value added to careers. According to the think tank's data, Ohio State graduates 10 years after enrollment report median annual earnings of approximately $60,400—about $19,600 below the ranking's overall average and more than $11,200 less than projected by the institute's model.
The index listed Ohio State at 83rd for payback on education investment, noting that it typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than the 2.5-year benchmark. In another educational metric, Ohio State ranked 18th for value added to education.
Peer Comparisons and University Silence
On the national leaderboard, Purdue University finished directly ahead of Ohio State, taking eighth place with a 67.7 score. Ohio State finished ahead of 10th-place Yale University and the University of Michigan–Ann Arbor, which placed 32nd. On the national list, Ohio State finished ahead of other evaluated institutions, including Case Western Reserve University at 66th, Kenyon College at 87th, and Oberlin College at 115th. Nationwide, the University of Texas at Austin led the rankings, followed by the University of Florida and the University of Notre Dame.
As of Wednesday, Nov. 11, Ohio State University had posted no official statement or reaction regarding the rankings.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
Supporting evidence (15)
In college rankings published by City Journal, Ohio State University placed ninth overall with an overall weighted score of 67.38 out of 100.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
In college rankings published by City Journal, Ohio State University placed ninth overall with an overall weighted score of 67.38 out of 100.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
City Journal is published by the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
Ohio State's top-10 placement was marked by stark internal contrasts: while the university scored near the top in governance and civics metrics, it ranked 101st in Value Added to Career with a score of 4.60 out of 16, and 83rd for payback on education investment with 7.30 out of 13.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
Instead, the think tank's model assigned heavy weight to ideological and governance priorities, including viewpoint diversity through "Heterodox Infrastructure" and "Commitment to Meritocracy".
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
On its institutional profile page, Ohio State earned a score of 20.20 out of 30 for educational quality, ranking fifth in that category.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
In the category's underlying breakdown, Ohio State ranked second nationwide for heterodox infrastructure.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
The Manhattan Institute also ranked Ohio State fourth nationally for commitment to meritocracy.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
In sharp contrast to its governance standing, Ohio State struggled in career metrics, placing 101st in value added to careers.
Read supporting passage
OSU profile page: '9 Overall Rank', 'Ohio State University Columbus, OH'. 'Overall Weighted Score: 67.38 / 100'. Category ranks shown: Heterodox Infrastructure 2, Commitment to Meritocracy 4, Value Added to Career 101, Traditional History Curriculum 95. Educational Quality 20.20 / 30 (#5). The text says median earnings are about '11,200 less than predicted' and 'It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.'
The index listed Ohio State at 83rd for payback on education investment, noting that it typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than the 2.5-year benchmark.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
In another educational metric, Ohio State ranked 18th for value added to education.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
On the national leaderboard, Purdue University finished directly ahead of Ohio State, taking eighth place with a 67.7 score.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
Ohio State finished ahead of 10th-place Yale University and the University of Michigan–Ann Arbor, which placed 32nd.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
On the national list, Ohio State finished ahead of other evaluated institutions, including Case Western Reserve University at 66th, Kenyon College at 87th, and Oberlin College at 115th.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
Nationwide, the University of Texas at Austin led the rankings, followed by the University of Florida and the University of Notre Dame.
Read supporting passage
Rankings list (https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/rankings), with 115 schools listed: #1 The University of Texas at Austin 79.7; #2 University of Florida 78.1; #3 University of Notre Dame 75.7; #8 Purdue University 67.7; #9 Ohio State University 67.4 (highlights: Heterodox Infrastructure 14.30 #2, Commitment to Meritocracy 9.50 #4, Value Added to Education 6.95 #18; drawbacks: Payback Education Investment 7.30 #83, Traditional History Curriculum 0.28 #95, Value Added to Career 4.60 #101); #10 Yale University 66.5; #32 University of Michigan–Ann Arbor 59.1; #66 Case Western Reserve University 46.0; #87 Kenyon College 41.1; #115 Oberlin College 18.3.
https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/about
Supporting evidence (2)
According to the index's methodology, the evaluation scored 115 colleges on 95 variables across campus governance, educational experience, student life, and career outcomes, leaving out measures of past prestige, admissions selectivity, or incoming test scores.
Read supporting passage
For City Journal’s 2026 College Rankings, we scored 115 of the country’s most prominent schools on 95 variables measuring campus governance, educational experience, student life, and career outcomes.
Across all 115 colleges evaluated, no institution scored above 80, with the publisher reporting an average nationwide score of 50.
Read supporting passage
On our 100-point scale, not one of these 115 schools scored above 80. Only seven earned a 70 or higher. Eighty-seven received scores below 60. The average score of an American school of higher education this year was an abysmal 50/100.
https://collegerankings.city-journal.org/school/ohio-state-university-main-campus
Supporting evidence (4)
In its summary of that infrastructure, the profile notes that the Salmon P. Chase Center for Civics, Culture, and Society, established by the Ohio General Assembly in 2023, exposes students to foundational debates on constitutional order, free societies, and responsible citizenship.
Read supporting passage
At its center is the Salmon P. Chase Center for Civics, Culture, and Society, established by the Ohio General Assembly in 2023. The center exposes students to the major works and debates of free societies, the American constitutional order, and the foundations of responsible leadership and informed citizenship.
The profile states that the university reaffirmed that commitment as faculty job postings no longer require diversity statements or express preferences for minority candidates, and protected-class criteria have been eliminated from scholarship awards.
Read supporting passage
The university has also reaffirmed its commitment to meritocracy: faculty job advertisements no longer require diversity statements or express preferences for minority candidates and protected-class criteria have been eliminated from scholarship awards.
According to the think tank's data, Ohio State graduates 10 years after enrollment report median annual earnings of approximately $60,400—about $19,600 below the ranking's overall average and more than $11,200 less than projected by the institute's model.
Read supporting passage
median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are approximately $60,400—roughly $19,600 below the overall average and more than $11,200 less than predicted. It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.
The index listed Ohio State at 83rd for payback on education investment, noting that it typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than the 2.5-year benchmark.
Read supporting passage
median annual earnings ten years after initial enrollment are approximately $60,400—roughly $19,600 below the overall average and more than $11,200 less than predicted. It typically takes three years to recoup the cost of an Ohio State education, longer than our 2.5-year benchmark.