Video 0:31
Video
Gary Keesee Jr. convicted on all 27 felony sexual assault charges in Knox County bench trial
Read the full articleKnox County Common Pleas Judge Richard Wetzel found Gary Keesee Jr. guilty on all 27 felony counts, including 11 rape charges carrying life in prison. Keesee's bond was continued with passport surrender pending sentencing at a later date.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/ex-faith-life-church-leader-145737791.html
Supporting evidence (10)
Knox County Common Pleas Court Judge Richard Wetzel delivered a verdict on Nov. 6 on 27 felony charges.
Read supporting passage
Knox County Common Pleas Court Judge Richard Wetzel delivered the verdict on Nov. 6 on 27 felony charges
Judge Wetzel found Keesee guilty of 11 counts of rape of a child under age 13, 11 counts of gross sexual imposition, and five lesser felony counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor.
Read supporting passage
Wetzel found Keesee guilty of 11 counts of rape of a child under the age of 13 and 11 counts of gross sexual imposition. Keesee was also found guilty of five counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor.
The rape counts carry a sentence of life in prison.
Following the reading of the verdict, Judge Wetzel continued Keesee's bond and allowed him to remain free pending formal sentencing at a later date, requiring him to surrender his passport as a condition of release.
Read supporting passage
Wetzel continued Keesee's bond and allowed him to remain free following the reading of the verdict. Keesee has surrendered his passport as part of his bond conditions. He will be formally sentenced at a later date.
Gary and Drenda Keesee, along with Tom Keesee's wife, Alexis, were present for the Nov. 6 hearing.
Read supporting passage
Gary and Drenda Keesee, along with Tom Keesee's wife, Alexis, attended the Nov. 6 hearing.
According to court records, prosecutors said Keesee sexually assaulted four girls between 2002 and 2016 who ranged in age from 6 to 15 years old, with the conduct beginning when Keesee was 12.
Read supporting passage
The Licking County Prosecutor's Office, working as a special prosecutor on the case, said Keesee sexually assaulted four girls, who ranged in age from 6 to 15 years old, between 2002 and 2016. He was 12 when the abuse began, according to court records.
Court records show one woman came forward with allegations in February 2025 before additional accusers came forward weeks later.
Read supporting passage
Keesee was a youth leader and chief media officer at the church before resigning in August 2024. The records show one woman came forward with the allegations in February 2025 before others did so weeks later.
In closing arguments, Shamansky contended that the accusers coordinated a smear campaign against Keesee, who did not testify, and maintained that prosecutors failed to prove physical harm.
Read supporting passage
Defense attorney Sam Shamansky argued the women coordinated a smear campaign against Keesee, who didn't take the stand during the trial.
Keesee served as a youth leader and chief media officer at the church before resigning in August 2024.
Read supporting passage
Keesee was a youth leader and chief media officer at the church before resigning in August 2024. The records show one woman came forward with the allegations in February 2025 before others did so weeks later.
Judge Wetzel will formally sentence Keesee at a later date.
Read supporting passage
Wetzel continued Keesee's bond and allowed him to remain free following the reading of the verdict. Keesee has surrendered his passport as part of his bond conditions. He will be formally sentenced at a later date.
Gary Keesee Jr. waives jury trial in Knox County sexual abuse case
Supporting evidence (2)
Previously, Pique reported that Keesee waived his jury trial in the sexual abuse case and that the judge took 27 felony charges under advisement.
Read supporting passage
Gary Keesee Jr. waives jury trial in Knox County sexual abuse case
A special prosecutor from Licking County handled the case, with Jenny Wells appointed to lead the state's prosecution team.
Read supporting passage
A special prosecutor from Licking County is handling the case because Drenda Keesee serves as a Knox County commissioner. Jenny Wells was appointed to lead the state's prosecution team.
Judge takes 27 felony charges against Gary Keesee Jr. under advisement, schedules Nov. 6 verdict
Supporting evidence (2)
Previously, Pique reported that Keesee waived his jury trial in the sexual abuse case and that the judge took 27 felony charges under advisement.
Read supporting passage
Judge takes 27 felony charges against Gary Keesee Jr. under advisement, schedules Nov. 6 verdict
In closing arguments, Special Prosecutor Jenny Wells argued that the three accusers endured years of silence under pressure from church culture, asserting that church teachings discouraged members from exposing leaders' wrongdoing.
Read supporting passage
Wells argued that the three accusers endured years of silence under pressure from church culture, asserting that the church taught them to cover the man and not expose his sins.
Supporting evidence (4)
Over four days, Judge Wetzel heard testimony from 11 witnesses, including three victims.
The alleged victims said the abuse occurred at the family's Mount Vernon property or victims' homes.
Read supporting passage
The alleged victims say the abuse occurred at the Keesee family's Mount Vernon property or at the victim's homes.
In closing arguments, Shamansky contended that the accusers coordinated a smear campaign against Keesee, who did not testify, and maintained that prosecutors failed to prove physical harm.
Read supporting passage
Shamansky argued there is not proof beyond reasonable doubt that victims suffered physical harm from their accusations.
Faith Life Church is a non-denominational church serving New Albany and Powell, led by Gary and Drenda Keesee.
Read supporting passage
Faith Life Church is a non-denominational church that serves the New Albany and Powell communities, lead by Gary and Drenda Keesee.
Supporting evidence (6)
Captain Gus Moore of the Licking County Sheriff's Office testified that he interviewed three victims and saw no indication they were coordinating stories.
Read supporting passage
Captain Gus Moore of the Licking County Sheriff’s Office testified about initial case documents and that he interviewed victims 1, 2, and 3. He said he saw no indication they were being coached, making up stories, or coordinating stories.
Defense counsel Shamansky called only one witness, Gary Thomas Keesee Sr., who testified that at that time nothing suggested sexual abuse.
Read supporting passage
Shamansky called only one witness, Gary Thomas Keesee Sr.
Defense counsel Shamansky called only one witness, Gary Thomas Keesee Sr., who testified that at that time nothing suggested sexual abuse.
Read supporting passage
Keesee Sr. testified there was nothing at that time to suggest sexual abuse.
Defense attorney Samuel Shamansky cited Rule 29 to request dismissal of counts 28 through 32 on Monday.
Read supporting passage
Defense attorney Samuel Shamansky cited Rule 29 in asking Knox County Common Pleas Judge Richard Wetzel to dismiss counts 28 through 32 on Monday.
The counts related to Victim 4 and included two rape charges and three gross sexual imposition charges, which Judge Wetzel dismissed based on her inability to return for cross-examination.
Read supporting passage
The counts related to Victim 4 and include two first-degree rape charges and three gross sexual imposition charges. The sexual imposition charges are third-degree felonies.
The counts related to Victim 4 and included two rape charges and three gross sexual imposition charges, which Judge Wetzel dismissed based on her inability to return for cross-examination.
Read supporting passage
Wetzel dismissed the counts based on her inability to return for cross-examination.
https://www.knoxpages.com/2026/09/29/gary-tom-keesee-jr-waives-right-to-jury-trial/
Supporting evidence (4)
A Knox County grand jury returned a 27-count indictment on April 20.
Authorities later added five additional charges after a fourth victim came forward.
Read supporting passage
Authorities added five additional charges on May 18, 2025: two rape and three gross sexual imposition counts. According to Capt. Jay Cook of the Licking County Sheriff’s Office, the additional counts stemmed from a fourth victim coming forward.
When court resumed at the Knox Memorial Building after 11 jurors were seated, Keesee waived his right to a jury trial.
Read supporting passage
Jury selection began Tuesday morning at the Knox Memorial Building. Eleven jurors were seated when the court recessed for lunch. Keesee officially waived his right to a jury trial when court resumed.
Knox County Prosecutor Chip McConville recused his office from the case, citing a conflict of interest because his office represents the Knox County Board of Commissioners, where Keesee's mother, Drenda Keesee, serves as an elected commissioner.
Read supporting passage
Knox County Prosecutor Chip McConville recused himself, citing a conflict of interest as he represents the Knox County Board of Commissioners. Keesee’s mother, Drenda Keesee, is a Knox County commissioner.
Supporting evidence (2)
Church leaders said the allegations did not involve church operations and affirmed that the church cooperated with the investigation.
Read supporting passage
Faith Life Church leaders have said the allegations do not involve the church and that the church has cooperated with the investigation.
The three alleged victims were members of the church, though officials said no evidence indicated abuse occurred on church property.
Read supporting passage
The three alleged victims were members of the church, though officials have said there is no evidence any of the alleged abuse occurred on church property.