Video 0:46
Video
Columbus School Board Committee Backs Highland Closure, Splits on Deficit Plan
Read the full articleA Columbus school board joint committee voted to recommend closing Highland Elementary and cutting high school busing, but declined to recommend closing Siebert Elementary or the district's two prep academies. The advisory recommendations head to the board ahead of December votes.
How we know this
The sources and records behind this story, with the facts they support.
Supporting evidence (12)
At its meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, Columbus City Schools board committee members split the administration's $50 million budget-reduction package and voted on building closures one at a time.
Read supporting passage
At its Nov. 11, 2026 joint committee meeting (Academic & Facility Alignment + Equitable & Transparent Resource committees; BoardDocs meeting DZ8HYE4AC3EE), Columbus City Schools board committee members split the administration's $50M FY28 budget-reduction package and voted on building closures one at a time.
In separate roll calls, the committee recommended closing Highland Elementary School, but motions to recommend closing Siebert Elementary School and the two single-gender academies failed.
Read supporting passage
Motion to recommend closing Columbus City Preparatory School for Girls and Columbus City Preparatory School for Boys: FAILED. - ~3:13-3:14: Motion to recommend closing Siebert: FAILED (mixed yes/no roll call). - ~3:14: Motion to recommend closing Highland: PASSED (roll call heard as all 'yes'). - ~3:16:39-3:16:52 recap by the chair: 'Columbus School for Girls and Boys together, they failed... You did not recommend Siebert but you recommended Highland.'
The joint committee also approved a motion to recommend non-personnel and transportation reductions to the board for consideration.
Read supporting passage
Motion to recommend the NON-PERSONNEL and TRANSPORTATION reductions to the board for consideration; roll call heard as all 'yes' (passed).
The two single-gender academies had to be voted together because of Title IX.
Under the administration's plan, the Boys Prep building would house an online academy, adult education, and a student support center, while the Girls Prep building would become the Columbus Gifted Academy.
Read supporting passage
Boys Prep building would house the online academy, adult education and a student support center; Girls Prep building would become the Columbus Gifted Academy; Highland would close as a neighborhood school and become west-side swing space; Siebert would close with no repurposing recommendation.
The proposal called for Highland Elementary to become west-side swing space upon closing as a neighborhood school, while Siebert Elementary faced proposed closure with no repurposing recommendation.
Read supporting passage
Boys Prep building would house the online academy, adult education and a student support center; Girls Prep building would become the Columbus Gifted Academy; Highland would close as a neighborhood school and become west-side swing space; Siebert would close with no repurposing recommendation.
A committee co-chair framed the role as advisory, stating that it does not constitute final approval of any closure, realignment, or individual budget reduction.
Read supporting passage
A co-chair framed the committee's role as advisory: deciding whether the administration's package is sufficiently supported to advance to the full board; 'It does not constitute final approval of any closure, realignment, or individual budget reduction.'
The committee chair confirmed that items not recommended still go to the board, noting that it does not mean the board will not consider them.
Read supporting passage
Chair: items not recommended still go to the board ('It doesn't mean the board won't consider it');
Administration officials noted that any realignment not recommended would have to be added to the personnel-reduction line of $30.951 million.
Read supporting passage
Administration said realignment savings were estimated from the Broadleigh/Moler/Fairwood consolidations, ~40% tied to positions, and any realignment not recommended would have to be added to the personnel-reduction line ($30.951M).
Following the split recommendations, the administration announced it will redo the calculations affecting transportation and personnel numbers and present them to the board alongside the original proposal.
Read supporting passage
administration to redo the math (affects transportation and personnel numbers) and present it to the board along with the original proposal.
Treasurer Ryan Cook stated that the state share of CCS funding fell from just above 35% in 2022 to 12% and is projected to hit the 10% statutory floor next fiscal year.
Read supporting passage
Treasurer Ryan Cook said the state share of CCS funding fell from just above 35% (2022) to 12% now and is projected to hit the 10% statutory floor next fiscal year.
Administration officials said the school board will receive a series of resolutions in December, noting that no decisions have been made while the community survey remains open.
Read supporting passage
Administration said the board will be presented a series of resolutions at its first December meeting; 'no decisions have been made'; the community survey is still open.
Supporting evidence (5)
District plans outline $3,649,000 in non-personnel reductions across equipment, technology, professional services, supplies, and utilities, alongside a $3.8 million transportation change for grades 9 through 12 using Central Ohio Transit Authority passes and yellow buses for students with more than one transfer.
Read supporting passage
Path to $50M: School Realignment $11.6M; 9-12 Transportation change $3.8M (the COTA/CCS workgroup option: COTA passes plus yellow bus for students with more than one transfer); FY2028 non-personnel $3,649,000 (equipment & technology $1,725,000; professional services $713,000; school discretionary $500,000; software $356,000; supplies $150,000; utilities $133,000; PD/travel $72,000); Administrative, Certificated and Classified Personnel Reductions $30,951,000. TOTAL $50,000,000.
District materials warn that approximately 400 positions across all position types would be reduced if none of the recommendations are approved.
Read supporting passage
If none of the recommendations are approved: approximately 400 positions reduced (all position types); or approximately 420 certificated positions if only certificated; or 350-650 classified if only classified (based on average job class cost, salary + fringe).
District planning slides state that no final decisions have been made regarding realignment and busing.
Read supporting passage
Deck says 'No final decisions have been made on realignment and busing.'
District presentation records show that Columbus City Schools already cut $67.5 million from fiscal years 2025 through 2027, including administrative trims, busing adjustments, and staff reductions.
Read supporting passage
Already cut: 2025-26 $16.8M (non-personnel + 11 admin positions). 2027 more than $50.7M: 54 (21%) administrator jobs $7.1M; K-8 non-100% lottery busing $8.7M; consolidation $2M+; non-personnel $8.9M; 275 (6%) certificated positions $19.8M; 116 (3%) classified positions $6.1M. Total FY2025-27 reductions $67.5M.
Under the district's planning timeline, the school board will vote on options in December, with specific personnel reductions to be identified between February and May 2027.
Read supporting passage
Timeline: December 2026 recommendations (non-personnel & personnel); BOE will vote to move forward on various options in December; February-May 2027 identification of specific personnel reductions per board policy and employee agreements.
Columbus City Schools Unveils Multi-Year Consolidation Plan to Address $50 Million Deficit
Supporting evidence (1)
Previously, Pique Media reported on the district's multi-year consolidation plan to address a projected $50 million deficit.
Read supporting passage
Columbus City Schools Unveils Multi-Year Consolidation Plan to Address $50 Million Deficit
Supporting evidence (3)
District realignment records project that closing Highland Elementary in 2027–28 would yield $1.4 million in general fund savings and preserve $24.8 million in prior capital investments, with the building operating at 59.3% utilization with 267 students.
Read supporting passage
Highland 2027-28 (students to West Mound and Burroughs; Highland becomes swing space for a new West Broad): $1.4M general fund; preserves $24.8M prior capital investments. Highland 59.3% utilized (capacity 450, enrollment 267), opened 1895.
The proposal to close and repurpose the gender academies was projected to save $4.1 million in recurring general fund spending and avoid $1.2 million annually in permanent improvement costs.
Read supporting passage
Close/repurpose gender academies (Girls at Franklin Middle 36.9% utilized, 179 enrolled; Boys at Eastmoor Middle 19.3%, 83 enrolled); Gifted Academy (405 students, from Everett) to Franklin Middle: $4.1M recurring general fund; avoids $1.2M/yr Permanent Improvement.
Consolidating Siebert Elementary had been estimated to yield $1.7 million in annual savings.
Read supporting passage
Consolidate Siebert (Stewart becomes home school for <50 students in boundary; ~270 others to their southside elementaries): $1.7M [Oct. 15: $1.5M].
Supporting evidence (3)
For its Nov. 17, 2026 regular business meeting, the school board's agenda schedules action on a second reading of Board Policy 7105 regarding closing school buildings.
Read supporting passage
Nov. 17, 2026 REGULAR BOARD BUSINESS MEETING, 4. Board Matters: - 4.5 Second Reading on Board Policy 7105 (Closing School Buildings). Type: Action.
The Nov. 17 agenda also includes resolutions to reemploy Treasurer Ryan Cook and reemploy Internal Auditor L. Kevin O'Connor, extending both contracts effective Aug. 1, 2027, through July 31, 2030.
Read supporting passage
'The Columbus City Schools Board of Education desires to reemploy Ryan Cook as Treasurer effective August 1, 2027, through July 31, 2030.'
The Nov. 17 agenda also includes resolutions to reemploy Treasurer Ryan Cook and reemploy Internal Auditor L. Kevin O'Connor, extending both contracts effective Aug. 1, 2027, through July 31, 2030.
Read supporting passage
Reemploys L. Kevin O'Connor as Internal Auditor effective August 1, 2027, through July 31, 2030.
Supporting evidence (1)
Board member Sarah Ingles presented the first reading of Board Policy 7105 at the board's Nov. 4 meeting.
Read supporting passage
Sarah Ingles presented the First Reading of Board Policy 7105 - Closing School Buildings.
Supporting evidence (1)
District records state that determining candidates for closure will be guided by Policy 7105, ensuring an objective assessment.
Read supporting passage
Utilization of Board Policy 7105: Determining which schools are candidates for closure will be based on the 14 factors listed in Board Policy 7105, ensuring a balanced and objective assessment.